
Prime Minister Keir Starmer has announced that his government will fast-track a new emergency law to stop a controversial sentencing policy that critics say could unfairly benefit certain groups and discriminate against white men.
The plan is to bring this law into Parliament very quickly possibly within just one day so it can take effect before the original sentencing changes come into force on April 1, 2025.
The sentencing guidelines in question were created by the Sentencing Council, which helps judges decide what punishments to give people found guilty of crimes.
These new rules suggest that judges should look at detailed reports before sentencing people from certain groups, including young adults, people from ethnic or cultural minorities, pregnant women, and abuse survivors. The goal, according to the Council, is to make sentencing fairer by understanding more about the offender’s background and situation.
However, many people including government officials say this approach could lead to a “two-tier” justice system, where someone’s sentence is lighter or harsher depending on their race, religion, or background.
Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood has strongly criticized the Sentencing Council’s move, saying it allows for unequal treatment and is not acceptable in a fair legal system. She said she already wrote to the Council asking them to change the rules, but they refused.
Now, the government is taking stronger action. Mahmood confirmed that they are working on emergency legislation to block these rules before they go into effect. A source close to her said they hope to push the new law through Parliament in just 24 hours.
Opposition voices have also joined in. Shadow Justice Secretary Robert Jenrick said the new rules would mean white people, especially men, would be treated worse in court simply because of their background. He called it unfair and said taxpayers shouldn’t have to pay for a justice system that favors some groups over others.
The Sentencing Council, meanwhile, defended the guidelines. They say the goal is not to create special treatment but to make sure judges have all the right information to make fair decisions.
They believe understanding someone’s background can help courts avoid decisions that may lead to worse outcomes or repeat offenses.
Still, the government isn’t convinced. Mahmood has even started a wider review into the powers of the Sentencing Council, suggesting it may be time to rethink how much control this independent body should have especially when their decisions affect the whole justice system.
In the end, this situation highlights a bigger debate about fairness in the legal system: Should everyone be treated exactly the same, or should a person’s background be taken into account? Starmer’s government is making it clear that they believe in equal treatment for everyone and they’re ready to act fast to make sure that happens.